What is the Coal and Charcoal Difference?

In Gastronomicliving Blog 0 comments

difference between charcoal and coal

The coal and charcoal difference is pretty much confusing to many people. South Africa, a land of diverse cultures, boasts an equally vibrant culinary landscape. A tradition that stands out is the 'braai', South Africa's take on the beloved BBQ. This social gathering, much more than cooking meat over a flame, is a thread that weaves communities together, bringing forth an exquisite array of flame-kissed meats and tantalising flavours. Today, we'll navigate the intricate nuances of South African BBQ and distinguish the difference between charcoal and coal, shedding light on their significant role in the gastronomic journey.

Fuel for Thought: Unveiling the Charcoal and Coal Enigma

Before we light the proverbial fire on this exploration, let's dispel a common confusion: the charcoal vs. coal conundrum. These terms, often deemed interchangeable by the novice griller, both serve as fuel and create heat. However, the comparison ends there. Unleashing a superior 'braai' experience or any BBQ adventure begins with understanding the subtle and not-so-subtle differences between these two.
Charcoal, the heartthrob of the BBQ world, is produced by heating wood in an oxygen-depleted environment. The result? A carbon-rich fuel source that burns hotter, cleaner, and longer than its original form. Charcoal's unique capability to provide a steady heat makes it the preferred choice for BBQ enthusiasts, imbuing meats with a smoky, slightly sweet profile that we all relish.
In contrast, coal is a black or brownish sedimentary rock formed from fossilised plant matter. It's packed with energy, burning incredibly hot and for an extended duration. However, while its heat efficiency is commendable, coal's high sulphur content raises environmental and health concerns, often leaving a less desirable taste in your BBQ offerings.

Is Charcoal Made with Coal?

It's a common misconception that charcoal is made from coal, but in reality, the two are entirely different substances. Charcoal is derived from wood that's been subjected to high temperatures in an environment devoid of oxygen. This process, known as pyrolysis, leaves behind a carbon-rich residue - charcoal - which burns cleaner and hotter than the original wood.
Coal, on the other hand, is a naturally occurring fossil fuel formed over millions of years from decomposed plant matter under high pressure and heat. Its composition and the process it undergoes to make it an entirely different entity from charcoal, even though it might look somewhat similar to the untrained eye.

The Heat Factor: Charcoal vs Coal Temperature

A key factor to consider when choosing between charcoal and coal as your BBQ fuel is the temperature each can achieve and maintain. This can significantly impact the cooking process and, ultimately, the quality and flavour of the food you're grilling.

Coal's Temperature Profile

Coal, primarily due to its energy-packed composition, can achieve much higher temperatures than charcoal. The dense nature of coal allows it to burn at scorching heat, often exceeding 2000 degrees Fahrenheit (or about 1093 degrees Celsius). This high-temperature attribute can be particularly useful for processes requiring intense heat, such as forging metals.
In the context of BBQ, coal's high heat can help sear the surface of meats quickly, creating a delightful, flavourful crust. However, managing such high temperatures can be challenging and requires a certain level of expertise. The intense heat can easily lead to overcooking or burning, especially if the food isn't vigilantly monitored.

heat factorCharcoal's Temperature Profile

Charcoal, on the other hand, typically burns at temperatures between 700 and 1000 degrees Fahrenheit (or about 370 to 540 degrees Celsius). While it doesn't burn as hot as coal, charcoal provides a more controlled, steady, and manageable heat source. This makes it an ideal choice for slow cooking, allowing the food to cook evenly and thoroughly.
The relatively lower temperatures of charcoal make it easier to handle, especially for novice grillers or for home-based BBQ settings. Additionally, it offers the added benefit of imbuing food with a distinct, smoky flavour - a signature taste much loved in the BBQ world.
It's worth noting that while lump charcoal (made directly from hardwood) can reach higher temperatures and burn faster, briquettes (manufactured from sawdust and binders) provide more consistent heat but burn at slightly lower temperatures.
The choice between coal and charcoal should take into consideration not only the temperature profiles of these fuels but also the specific requirements of your BBQ - the food you're cooking, the desired flavour, and your level of grilling expertise. With this knowledge, you're well-equipped to fan the flames of a truly satisfying BBQ experience.

What is More Expensive: Coal or Charcoal?

Charcoal tends to be more expensive than coal. The pricing disparity arises from the different production processes the two undergo. Charcoal production is labour-intensive and requires a considerable amount of wood, making it a more costly fuel option.
Coal, on the other hand, is cheaper because it's a naturally occurring resource, mined directly from the earth. However, it's worth noting that while coal may be less expensive upfront, the potential health and environmental costs associated with its use may render it more costly in the long run.

Why is Coal Used for BBQ?

Despite the potential drawbacks, there are reasons why coal is used for BBQ. Coal burns at high heat and for a prolonged duration, making it an efficient choice for large-scale or long-duration grilling. It's particularly useful when cooking foods that require high temperatures, such as searing meats to achieve a perfect crust.
Moreover, its relative affordability compared to charcoal can make it an attractive option, especially for large gatherings or commercial purposes. However, it's important to remember that coal's high sulphur content can impart an undesired flavour to food and contribute to environmental pollution, making it a less preferred option for many BBQ aficionados.
As with everything, knowledge is power. Understanding the subtle and not-so-subtle differences between charcoal and coal can greatly enhance your 'braai' experience, helping you make informed choices that not only tantalise your taste buds, but also respect our precious environment.

charcoal vs. coalCharcoal vs. Activated Charcoal: The Battle of Benefits

When it comes to determining which is 'better' between charcoal and activated charcoal, it truly depends on the context of use. Each offers unique benefits suited to different applications, whether it be for grilling, health, or environmental purposes.

Charcoal: The BBQ Champion

Charcoal, particularly lump charcoal, is the star player in the BBQ world. It's favoured for its ability to provide steady, high heat, ideal for grilling. Moreover, charcoal imparts that desirable smoky flavour to foods, enhancing the overall gastronomic experience.
Charcoal is also relatively easy to handle, burns cleanly, and, in the case of lump charcoal, is a natural product made directly from hardwood. For these reasons, in the context of BBQ and grilling, traditional charcoal is the preferred choice.

Activated Charcoal: The Health and Environmental Hero

Activated charcoal, on the other hand, is not typically used for grilling. It's made similarly to regular charcoal, but an additional step - 'activation' through exposure to high temperatures with a gas that expands its surface area - sets it apart.
This activation process gives activated charcoal potent absorptive properties, making it a powerful tool in certain health and environmental applications. It's commonly used in medicine to help treat drug overdoses or poisonings, as it can absorb and help remove toxins from the body.
In environmental contexts, activated charcoal is used in water and air purification systems due to its ability to trap and remove pollutants. However, it's not typically used as a fuel source for cooking or BBQ due to its special properties and higher cost.

why coal is used in BBQ

Coal Vs. Charcoal: The BBQ Showdown

In the South African 'braai', and indeed in the global BBQ arena, the coal and charcoal difference plays a pivotal role in determining the taste, health implications, and environmental footprint of your grilling experience. While charcoal gifts your meats with a flavour profile that's hard to beat, coal's power-packed performance comes with an environmental asterisk.

Fanning the Flames of Gastronomic Living in Qatar

Navigating the intricate landscapes of BBQ fuels can be tricky, but with a firm grasp of the charcoal and coal difference, you're now well-equipped to take your grilling endeavours to the next level. And here's where Gastronomic Living steps in, delivering the ultimate BBQ experience right here in Qatar, tailored to your refined palate, keeping in mind your health and the environment.

Our Promise: A Delicious Conclusion

At Gastronomic Living, we breathe life into the rich South African BBQ culture in the heart of Qatar. Our mission is to transform your culinary landscape, curating a delicious and sustainable 'braai' experience that respects our precious environment while celebrating the diverse heritage of South African cuisine.
Ready to fan the flames of your culinary curiosity? Step into the enchanting world of gastronomic living, where every meal is a journey, and every bite, is a delightful discovery. With Gastronomic Living in Doha, you have the best quality South African meat for every BBQ experience. Knowing the coal and charcoal difference, you can now move every BBQ moment to the next level. Our online store covers everything you need from fresh and frozen meat, to wood and coal, and even BBQ grills and ovens. So, what are you waiting for? Contact us directly